Our review
This skill automates the replacement of a failed AI agent in a multi-agent system by coordinating with a manager, preserving work artifacts, creating a new agent, and handing off tasks.
Strengths
- Ensures continuity after terminal failures
- Preserves work artifacts to prevent loss
- Provides a validation checklist to guarantee handoff integrity
- Clearly defines roles between agent creator and orchestrator
Limitations
- Requires external manager approval (EAMA), which can introduce delay
- Depends on AI Maestro infrastructure for agent registration
- New agent has no memory of the old one, requiring comprehensive handoff documentation
Use this skill when an AI agent has failed permanently and manual replacement is undesirable.
Do not use it for temporary failures where recovery is possible, or in single-agent setups.
Security analysis
CautionThe skill involves network requests (curl) to a local AI Maestro API for agent replacement notifications. It does not perform destructive actions, exfiltrate data, or disable safety mechanisms. However, the use of bash commands and network communication warrants caution in misconfigured environments.
- •Uses curl commands to communicate with an internal API. While intended for local system messaging, improper configuration could expose the API. The commands include user-supplied agent names, which if not sanitized could lead to injection risks in naive implementations.
Examples
Request replacement approval for a failed agent by sending an urgent message to the manager. Use the AMCOS replacement protocol: curl -X POST "$AIMAESTRO_API/api/messages" -H "Content-Type: application/json" -d '{"to":"eama-assistant-manager","subject":"URGENT: Replace libs-svg-svgbbox","priority":"urgent","content":{"type":"replacement-request","message":"Terminal failure (3 crashes). Requesting replacement approval.","failed_agent":"libs-svg-svgbbox"}}'Notify the orchestrator about a newly created agent so it can generate handoff docs and update the kanban. Use: curl -X POST "$AIMAESTRO_API/api/messages" -H "Content-Type: application/json" -d '{"to":"eoa-orchestrator","subject":"Agent replaced: libs-svg-svgbbox","priority":"high","content":{"type":"replacement-notification","message":"Please generate handoff docs and update kanban.","old_agent":"libs-svg-svgbbox","new_agent":"replacement-agent-uuid"}}'name: amcos-agent-replacement description: Use when replacing a failed agent with a new instance. Trigger with agent replacement or failover events. user-invocable: false license: Apache-2.0 compatibility: Requires AI Maestro installed. metadata: author: Emasoft version: 1.0.0 context: fork agent: amcos-main
AMCOS Agent Replacement
Overview
Replace a failed agent when recovery has failed or failure is terminal. Covers failure confirmation, artifact preservation, manager approval, agent creation, orchestrator notification, and work handoff.
Prerequisites
- Failure classified as Terminal, or all recovery strategies exhausted
- AI Maestro running locally with agent registry accessible
- Handoff directory at
$CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR/thoughts/shared/handoffs/
Instructions
Phase 4: Agent Replacement Protocol
- Confirm failure -- verify all recovery strategies attempted or failure is terminal
- Preserve artifacts -- save recoverable work to
thoughts/shared/handoffs/AGENT_NAME/ - Request approval -- send
urgentreplacement request to EAMA; wait for approval - Create replacement -- use
ai-maestro-agents-managementskill - Notify EOA -- so it can generate handoff docs and update kanban
- Send handoff docs to new agent (validate with checklist below)
- Verify acknowledgment -- confirm new agent received handoff and began work
- Close incident -- log resolution, notify EAMA
See references/agent-replacement-protocol.md and references/op-replace-agent.md.
<!-- TOC: agent-replacement-protocol.md -->- Phase 1: Failure confirmation and artifact preservation
- Phase 2: Manager notification and approval
- ...and 8 more sections
Replacement Protocol Summary
Terminal failure -> AMCOS notifies EAMA -> EAMA approves
-> Create new agent -> Notify EOA (handoff + kanban)
-> Send handoff to new agent -> Agent acknowledges
Key Consideration: Memory Loss
CRITICAL: The replacement agent has NO MEMORY of the old agent. Therefore:
- EOA must generate handoff documentation
- EOA must reassign tasks in GitHub Project kanban
- AMCOS must send handoff docs to new agent
ROLE BOUNDARY: AMCOS creates agents and sends context. EOA owns task assignment.
Handoff Validation Checklist
- [ ] Required fields present (from/to/type/UUID/task/failed_agent/failure_reason)
- [ ] UUID is unique
- [ ] Target agent exists and is alive
- [ ] All referenced files exist
- [ ] No [TBD] placeholders
- [ ] Acceptance criteria defined
Output
| Phase | Output | |-------|--------| | Artifact preservation | Files saved to handoff directory | | Manager approval | Approval message from EAMA | | Agent creation | New agent online and registered | | Work handoff | Docs sent and acknowledged |
Error Handling
| Issue | Resolution | |-------|------------| | Manager does not respond | Wait 15 min, reminder, escalate to user | | New agent fails to register | Verify AI Maestro health and hooks | | Handoff rejected | Queue and retry in 5 minutes | | No artifacts recoverable | Document loss, notify EOA to recreate |
Examples
# Request replacement approval
curl -X POST "$AIMAESTRO_API/api/messages" \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{"to":"eama-assistant-manager","subject":"URGENT: Replace libs-svg-svgbbox","priority":"urgent","content":{"type":"replacement-request","message":"Terminal failure (3 crashes). Requesting replacement approval.","failed_agent":"libs-svg-svgbbox"}}'
# Notify orchestrator of replacement
curl -X POST "$AIMAESTRO_API/api/messages" \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{"to":"eoa-orchestrator","subject":"Agent replaced: libs-svg-svgbbox","priority":"high","content":{"type":"replacement-notification","message":"Please generate handoff docs and update kanban.","old_agent":"libs-svg-svgbbox","new_agent":"libs-svg-svgbbox-v2"}}'
Resources
- references/agent-replacement-protocol.md - Full replacement protocol
- references/op-replace-agent.md - Replace agent runbook
Docker Compose Architect
DevOps
Designs optimized Docker Compose configurations.
Incident Postmortem Writer
DevOps
Writes structured and blameless incident postmortem reports.
Runbook Creator
DevOps
Creates clear operational runbooks for common DevOps procedures.