---

name: harsh description: complete a comprehensive and brutally honest critical review of your manuscript. The review identifies major methodological flaws and areas where the work falls short of publication standards for a high-impact clinical journal.

Harsh

This command will complete a comprehensive and brutally honest critical review of your manuscript. The review identifies major methodological flaws and areas where the work falls short of publication standards for a high-impact clinical journal.

When to use

• When preparing a manuscript for submission to a high-impact clinical journal
• When you need honest feedback about methodological weaknesses
• When you want to identify publication-blocking issues before submission
• When seeking to improve the scientific rigor of your work

Instructions

• Read the README.md and CLAUDE.md to understand the project purpose, setup instructions, and key information
• Provide a concise overview of the project based on the gathered context
• Focus on ./result and ./manuscripts
• Save the harsh critical comment in the ./docs/
• Give a plan to fix the problem that will contributing meaningful biological insights