Our review
This tool simulates a ruthless reviewer to check intent-implementation consistency and logical triangulation in a paper draft.
Strengths
- Layered audit (compliance, triangulation matrix, defensive logic)
- Identifies gaps between claims and evidence
- Generates a comprehensive report with pass/fail/warn and verdicts
Limitations
- Requires a pre-existing checklist for compliance checks
- May miss issues not covered by the checklist
- Automated verdicts might lack contextual nuance
When you have a paper draft ready for review and need a systematic check of logical consistency and academic integrity.
For creative or stylistic editing, as the tool focuses on rigor and compliance rather than prose quality.
Security analysis
SafeThe skill uses only Read, Write, and Glob to audit paper drafts, with no execution of external commands, network access, or destructive file operations. It does not instruct exfiltration of secrets or disabling of safety controls.
No concerns found
Examples
Please audit my paper draft located at ./paper_draft.md using the paper-audit skill. Run all four layers and save the report to psmfiles/paper_audit_report.md.Perform only Layer 2 (Triangulation Matrix) on the abstract and results section of my paper. Compare each claim in the abstract with the evidence in the results and output a table of promises vs proof.Run Layer 3 (Defensive Audit) on my paper draft. Specifically check for baseline manipulation, ablation amnesia, figure-text consistency, variable continuity, and recency of citations. Output a summary of any issues found.name: paper-audit description: Audit paper drafts for logical consistency, compliance, and academic integrity (Triangulation Matrix). allowed-tools:
- Read
- Write
- Glob
Paper Audit Skill
Goal: Simulate a ruthless reviewer to check Intent-Implementation consistency and logical triangulation.
Workflow
-
Read Input: Read the user's paper draft (or specific sections).
-
Load Standards: Read
paper-audit/CHECKLIST.md. -
Execute Audit Layers:
-
Layer 1: Compliance Check:
- Check against
CHECKLIST.md. - Output Pass/Fail/Warn table.
- Check against
-
Layer 2: The Triangulation Matrix (Strict Verification):
- Compare Claims (Abstract/Intro) vs. Evidence (Experiments/Results).
- Output Table:
- Column 1: The Promise (Specific claims).
- Column 2: The Proof (Figure/Table #).
- Column 3: The Gap (Exact match or weak proxy?).
- Verdict: ✅ Validated / ⚠️ Weak Support / 🔴 Hallucination.
-
Layer 3: Defensive Audit (Logic Stress Test):
- Baseline Manipulation: Are weak baselines used?
- Ablation Amnesia: Are modules justified by ablations?
- Figure-Text Consistency: Do numbers match?
- Variable Continuity: Are symbols consistent?
- Recency Check: Are >50% citations from last 1-3 years?
-
Layer 4: The Decision:
- List top 3 Fatal Flaws.
- Mock Decision: Accept / Weak Accept / Major Revision / Reject.
-
-
Output:
- Save full report to
psmfiles/paper_audit_report.md.
- Save full report to
API Documentation Generator
Documentation
Automatically generates OpenAPI/Swagger API documentation.
Technical Writer
Documentation
Writes clear technical documentation following top style guides.
Pivot Decision Framework
Documentation
Documents a strategic pivot or persevere decision with evidence, analysis, and rationale. Use when evaluating whether to change direction on a product, feature, or strategy based on market feedback.