Skills Guide

Quality Review Procedure

VerifiedSafe

Objective evaluation procedure to verify deliverables meet requirements and quality standards. Includes a checklist covering accuracy, maintainability, security, and conformance to project rules. Outputs 'Approved' or 'Needs Changes' with specific constructive feedback.

Sby Skills Guide Bot
DevelopmentIntermediate
906/2/2026
Claude CodeCursorWindsurfCopilotCodex
#review#code-review#quality-assurance#checklist#feedback

Recommended for

Backend developerClaude CodeCode reviewCursorFrontend developerCopilot

Our review

An objective review procedure that evaluates deliverables against criteria of accuracy, maintainability, security, and conformance.

Strengths

  • Systematic review using a multi-criteria checklist
  • Detection of security and maintainability issues
  • Constructive and specific feedback when changes are needed

Limitations

  • May miss issues not covered by the checklist
  • Depends on the quality of predefined criteria
  • Risk of rigidity if the checklist is not context-adapted
When to use it

Use this skill before approving a deliverable to ensure it meets quality and security standards.

When not to use it

Do not use it for creative tasks where subjective judgment is more important than strict criteria.

Security analysis

Safe
Quality score82/100

The skill only provides a review checklist and does not execute any commands or access external resources. No security risks are introduced.

No concerns found

Examples

Code review for pull request
Review the following code changes for accuracy, maintainability, security, and conformance to project standards. Output approved or needs changes with specific feedback.
Documentation review
Review this document for completeness, clarity, and adherence to the project's documentation guidelines. Provide an approved or needs changes verdict.
Full project review
Perform a comprehensive review of the entire project to ensure it meets the quality criteria defined in our system definition. Report any deviations and suggest improvements.

name: skill-review description: 成果物が要件・品質基準を満たしているか客観的に評価するレビュー手続き。

Skill: レビュー手続き (Review)

概要

成果物が要件・品質基準・一貫性を満たしているか客観的に評価する。

Instructions

チェックリスト

  1. 正確性: 意図通りに動作し、バグが含まれていないか。
  2. 保守性: 命名は適切か、構造はシンプルか、ドキュメントは十分か。
  3. 安全性: セキュリティリスクや予期せぬ副作用がないか。
  4. 適合性: docs/system-definition.md やプロジェクト固有のルールに従っているか。

出力基準

  • 合格 (Approved) または 修正依頼 (Needs Changes)
  • 修正依頼の場合は、具体的かつ建設的なフィードバックを添える。
Related skills

Next.js App Router Expert

Development

A skill that turns Claude into a Next.js App Router expert.

Claude CodeCursoradvanced
890
234
2,846
Admin

README Generator

Development

Creates professional and comprehensive README.md files for your projects.

claudeCursorWindsurfbeginner
259
72
821
Admin

API Documentation Writer

Development

Generates comprehensive API documentation in OpenAPI/Swagger format.

claudeCursorWindsurfintermediate
156
44
682
Admin