name: executing-plans-review description: Verification, drift detection, and snapshot logic for executing-plans user-invocable: false allowed-tools:

Read
Glob
Grep
Bash
Edit
Write
Task
AskUserQuestion
mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__*

Verification and Review Phase Details

This document contains detailed verification, drift detection, and snapshot logic for the executing-plans skill.

Snapshot Saving

Save context snapshots to enable recovery after compaction events. This preserves the executing-plans skill's state and progress across context compaction.

When to Save

Call saveSnapshot() at these critical points:

After each wave of tasks completes
After full test suite passes (post-wave verification)
After each individual task completes (per-task verification)
Before asking for user feedback
At major milestones (all tasks complete)

Save Function

FUNCTION saveSnapshot():
  session = current session name

  // Read current state via MCP
  Tool: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__get_session_state
  Args: { "project": "<cwd>", "session": session }
  Returns: state = { "phase": "...", "completedTasks": [...], "pendingTasks": [...], ... }

  // Save snapshot via MCP
  Tool: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__save_snapshot
  Args: {
    "project": "<cwd>",
    "session": session,
    "activeSkill": "executing-plans",
    "currentStep": "implementation",
    "inProgressItem": null,
    "pendingQuestion": null,
    "recentContext": [
      {
        "type": "progress",
        "content": "Completed tasks: {state.completedTasks}. Pending: {state.pendingTasks}. Last wave: {wave number}"
      }
    ]
  }
  // Note: version and timestamp are automatically added

  // Update collab state to mark snapshot exists
  Tool: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__update_session_state
  Args: {
    "project": "<cwd>",
    "session": session,
    "hasSnapshot": true,
    "lastSnapshot": "<current-ISO-timestamp>"
  }

Save Points with Examples

After wave completes with test suite passing:

[Wave N tasks all complete]
-> Run full test suite: npm run test:ci
-> If tests FAIL: Stop, report failure (don't save)
-> If tests PASS:
   - saveSnapshot()
   - Update task diagram (all Wave N tasks -> "completed")
   - Show wave completion report
   - Proceed to next wave

Example snapshot after Wave 1:

{
  "version": 1,
  "timestamp": "2026-01-21T14:35:22Z",
  "activeSkill": "executing-plans",
  "currentStep": "implementation",
  "completedTasks": ["task-planning-skill", "gather-goals-types", "brainstorming-cleanup"],
  "pendingTasks": ["collab-routing", "executing-plans-tdd-skip", "pre-compact-script"],
  "recentContext": [
    {
      "type": "progress",
      "content": "Completed tasks: task-planning-skill, gather-goals-types, brainstorming-cleanup. Pending: 3 tasks. Last wave: 1"
    }
  ]
}

After each task completes (per-task verification):

[Task execution completes]
-> Compare implementation against design doc
-> Check for drift
-> If verification PASSES:
   - saveSnapshot() with updated completedTasks list
   - Unlock dependent tasks
   - Proceed to next ready task
-> If verification FAILS:
   - Keep task as in_progress
   - Request fixes before saving

Before batch completion report:

[All ready tasks complete, about to report to user]
-> saveSnapshot()
-> Show progress report with completed tasks
-> Show which tasks are ready next
-> Wait for user feedback

At final completion:

[All tasks complete and verified]
-> saveSnapshot()
-> Show implementation summary
-> Invoke finishing-a-development-branch skill
-> (After finishing-a-development-branch completes: cleanup collab session)

Step 2.5: Per-Task Verification (Collab Workflow)

When within a collab workflow, run verification after each task completes:

Verification Steps:

After task completion, trigger verify-phase hook (if available)
Compare task output against design doc specification
Check for drift:
- Are implemented interfaces matching design?
- Any undocumented additions?
- Missing components?

On Verification Success:

Mark task as verified
Update collab-state.json: move task from pendingTasks to completedTasks
Update lastActivity timestamp
Unlock dependent tasks
Proceed to next ready tasks

FUNCTION markTaskComplete(taskId):
  session = current session name

  // 1. Read current state
  Tool: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__get_session_state
  Args: { "project": "<cwd>", "session": session }
  Returns: state = { "completedTasks": [...], "pendingTasks": [...], ... }

  // 2. Move task from pending to completed
  newCompleted = [...state.completedTasks, taskId]
  newPending = state.pendingTasks.filter(t => t !== taskId)

  // 3. Update session state via MCP (updates progress bar)
  Tool: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__update_session_state
  Args: {
    "project": "<cwd>",
    "session": session,
    "completedTasks": newCompleted,
    "pendingTasks": newPending
  }

  // 4. Update task execution diagram (visual progress)
  // Change from executing (blue) to completed (green)
  Tool: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__patch_diagram
  Args: {
    "project": "<cwd>",
    "session": session,
    "id": "task-execution",
    "old_string": "style {taskId} fill:#bbdefb,stroke:#1976d2,stroke-width:3px",  // executing
    "new_string": "style {taskId} fill:#c8e6c9,stroke:#2e7d32"                    // completed
  }
  // If patch fails (task wasn't marked executing), try from waiting state:
  // old_string: "style {taskId} fill:#e0e0e0,stroke:#9e9e9e"  // waiting

IMPORTANT: You MUST call markTaskComplete(taskId) after each task passes verification. This:

Updates the progress bar in the UI (completedTasks/pendingTasks)
Updates the task execution diagram (visual green checkmark)

On Verification Failure:

Keep task as in_progress (not completed)
Show drift report with pros/cons
Ask user: accept drift, reject and fix, or review each
If drift accepted: update design doc, then unlock dependents
If drift rejected: fix implementation before proceeding

Unlocking Dependents:

for each task T where T.depends-on includes completed_task:
  if all(T.depends-on) are completed:
    move T from pending to ready

Step 2.6: Drift Detection

After implementer reports completion, check for drift:

Step 1: Read design doc and implementation

Read design doc: Tool: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__get_document Args: { "project": "<cwd>", "session": "<session>", "id": "design" }
Read implemented files (from task's file list)

Step 2: Compare implementation to design

FOR each function/type in the task's Interface section: Compare: - Function name matches? - Parameter names and types match? - Return type matches? - Logic follows Pseudocode steps?

IF mismatch found: ADD to drift_list: { type: "signature" | "logic" | "scope" | "missing", design_says: <from design doc>, implementation_has: <from code>, file: <file path>, line: <line number if applicable> }

Step 3: If drift detected, analyze and present

IF drift_list is not empty: FOR each drift in drift_list:

Analyze:
  severity = assess_severity(drift)  // contract vs detail
  intent = assess_intent(drift)      // improvement vs misunderstanding
  precedent = assess_precedent(drift) // will this encourage more drift?
  reversibility = assess_reversibility(drift)

Generate pros:
  - [benefit of keeping this change]
  - [another benefit if applicable]

Generate cons:
  - [drawback of keeping this change]
  - [another drawback if applicable]

Determine recommendation:
  IF drift.type == "signature": recommend = "REJECT"
  ELSE IF drift.type == "logic" AND same_result: recommend = "ACCEPT"
  ELSE IF drift.type == "scope": recommend = "REJECT"
  ELSE IF drift.type == "missing": recommend = "REJECT"

Present to user:
  ```
  DRIFT DETECTED in task [task-id]:

  ## What Changed
  | Type | Design Says | Implementation Has |
  |------|-------------|-------------------|
  | {drift.type} | {drift.design_says} | {drift.implementation_has} |

  ## Analysis

  **Pros of keeping this change:**
  - {pro1}
  - {pro2}

  **Cons of keeping this change:**
  - {con1}
  - {con2}

  **Suggested choice:** {recommend}
  **Reasoning:** {explanation based on severity, intent, precedent, reversibility}

  ## Your Decision
  1. Reject - revert and re-implement per design
  2. Accept - update design doc to include this change
  3. Discuss - need more context before deciding
  ```

Step 4: Handle user decision

IF user chooses "Reject":

Do NOT mark task as complete
Tell implementer to re-implement per design
Return to Step 2 (re-execute task)

IF user chooses "Accept":

Read current design doc
Update relevant section to match implementation
Write updated design doc via MCP
Log decision in Decision Log section
Mark task as complete
Proceed to next task

IF user chooses "Discuss":

Pause execution
Gather more context from user
Re-present options after discussion

Step 5: No drift case

IF drift_list is empty:

Mark task as complete
Proceed to next task

Proposing Design Doc Changes

When drift is detected and requires a design doc update, use the proposed tag:

For section-level changes:

<!-- status: proposed: <drift-description> -->
<new-section-content>

For inline changes:

<!-- propose-start: <drift-description> --><new-text><!-- propose-end -->

Process:

Identify the unique text at the insertion point

Use patch to insert proposed content:

Tool: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__patch_document
Args: {
  "project": "<cwd>",
  "session": "<session>",
  "id": "design",
  "old_string": "<unique text at insertion point>",
  "new_string": "<unique text><!-- propose-start: description --><content><!-- propose-end -->"
}

If patch fails (not unique), fall back to full update: mcp__plugin_mermaid-collab_mermaid__update_document({ "id": "design", "content": <updated> })
Notify user: "Proposed change visible in design doc (cyan). Accept/reject in mermaid-collab UI."
Wait for user decision before proceeding

After user decision:

If accepted: proposed marker removed, content remains -> continue execution
If rejected: content removed -> address the drift differently or stop

Vérification et Revue des Plans d'Exécution