Notre avis
Orchestre une boucle stricte de revue et d'exécution qui applique brutal-project-review à chaque sous-système et exécute toutes les tâches via task-worker, en répétant les passes jusqu'à ce qu'aucun nouveau problème critique ou majeur ne soit trouvé.
Points forts
- Garantit qu'aucune instruction des compétences source n'est perdue
- Processus autonome à plusieurs passes qui approfondit le raffinement
- Reprend en toute sécurité en vidant d'abord les tâches existantes
- Intègre le contexte du projet à partir de TARGET.md
Limites
- Limité aux projets avec des sous-systèmes bien définis
- Nécessite que les compétences brutal-project-review et task-worker soient disponibles
- La boucle peut être longue pour les grandes bases de code
À utiliser lorsque vous avez besoin d'une amélioration approfondie et autonome d'un projet par une revue itérative et une exécution des tâches jusqu'à ce qu'aucun problème majeur ne subsiste.
À éviter lorsque vous avez besoin d'une correction rapide ou lorsque le projet manque de limites claires entre sous-systèmes.
Analyse de sécurité
SûrThe skill is an orchestrator that reads two other skill files and loops subsystem reviews and task execution. It only uses safe Bash commands (ls, find, wc, date, git, ./run, mkdir, rm, cat, mv) and standard editing tools. There are no instructions for destructive actions, exfiltration, or disabling safety. The rm tool is allowed but not explicitly invoked with dangerous patterns; cleanup is left to invoked skills. No network access is requested. The orchestrator itself is passive and does not execute user-provided code.
Aucun point d'attention détecté
Exemples
Apply the brutal-agent to systematically review all subsystems and execute tasks until no critical issues remain.Run a brutal-agent pass on my project, checking TARGET.md first and draining any existing tasks.Use the brutal-agent loop to harden the codebase, ensuring each subsystem is reviewed and tasks are completed.name: brutal-agent description: "Orchestrate subsystem-by-subsystem project hardening by combining brutal-project-review and task-worker in a strict loop: review one subsystem, create CRITICAL/MAJOR tasks, run all tasks to completion, then move to the next subsystem. Continue full review/task passes until a complete pass finds no new CRITICAL/MAJOR issues. Use when the user wants both deep subsystem review and autonomous task execution with no instruction loss." allowed-tools: Bash(ls:), Bash(find:), Bash(wc:), Bash(date:), Bash(git:), Bash(./run:), Bash(mkdir:), Bash(rm:), Bash(cat:), Bash(mv:), Task, Read, Write, Edit, Grep, Glob
Run a strict orchestration loop that combines these two skills without dropping any instructions:
/home/user/.codex/skills/brutal-project-review/SKILL.md/home/user/.codex/skills/task-worker/SKILL.md
Non-Negotiable Inheritance Rules
- Read both source
SKILL.mdfiles in full before starting. - Treat every instruction in both source files as authoritative and preserved.
- Do not summarize away, simplify, or omit any requirement from either source skill.
- Only add orchestration logic for ordering. If there is tension, preserve source-skill behavior and use this skill only to decide sequence.
Orchestration Workflow
Step 0: Load Source Skills
- Read:
/home/user/.codex/skills/brutal-project-review/SKILL.md/home/user/.codex/skills/task-worker/SKILL.md
- Keep their instructions active for the rest of execution.
Step 0.5: Load Project Target Context (Before Feature Planning)
- Before planning any feature work, check for
TARGET.mdin the project root directory. - If
TARGET.mdexists, read it in full and treat it as required planning context. - Do not start feature planning until this check/read has been completed.
Step 1: Drain Existing Tasks First (Resume Safety)
- If any task exists in either:
workspace/tasks/in-progress/workspace/tasks/todo/
- Run
task-workerexactly as specified, until it reports no more tasks. - This prevents reviewing additional subsystems while previous findings remain unaddressed.
Step 1.5: Initialize Pass Tracking
- Define a "pass" as reviewing all currently discovered subsystems to
doneonce. - Read
.claude/review-state/manifest.jsonand record:pass_started_atpass_baseline_tasks_created = len(tasks_created)(use0if manifest does not yet exist)
- Use this baseline to determine whether the pass discovered any new CRITICAL/MAJOR issues.
Step 2: Review One Subsystem
- Run
brutal-project-reviewexactly as specified. - Execute one full subsystem cycle (including report, task creation, manifest update, completion marking, and cleanup) for the next pending subsystem.
Step 3: Run All Tasks to Completion
- Immediately run
task-workerexactly as specified. - Let it process continuously until both are empty:
workspace/tasks/todo/workspace/tasks/in-progress/
- Respect all TDD, self-review, fix-loop, verification, state, and lifecycle requirements from
task-worker.
Step 4: Loop Control
- Check
brutal-project-reviewmanifest state. - If any subsystem remains pending, go back to Step 2.
- If all subsystems are done:
- Compute
pass_new_tasks = len(tasks_created) - pass_baseline_tasks_created. - If
pass_new_tasks > 0, start another pass:- Reinitialize pass tracking (Step 1.5)
- Go back to Step 2
- If
pass_new_tasks == 0, go to Step 5.
- Compute
Step 5: Final Drain and Completion Report
- Run one final
task-workerpass to ensure no residual tasks remain. - Stop only when this condition is true:
- Last complete pass produced
pass_new_tasks == 0(no new CRITICAL/MAJOR issues found)
- Last complete pass produced
- Report completion summary:
- Passes executed
- New CRITICAL/MAJOR tasks created in last pass (
0) - Subsystems reviewed (done/total)
- Remaining tasks (must be zero unless explicitly blocked/needs-human-review)
- Any blocked or needs-human-review tasks
Execution Contract
When this skill says “run brutal-project-review” or “run task-worker”, it means:
- Apply the full, original instructions from each referenced source skill.
- Preserve all required formats, severity definitions, state handling, history updates, commits, and review rigor.
- Preserve all resume logic and guardrails from both skills.
This skill only defines the macro-ordering loop:
- Review one subsystem
- Run all tasks
- When a full pass completes, repeat passes until no new CRITICAL/MAJOR tasks are created
Expert Next.js App Router
Developpement
Un skill qui transforme Claude en expert Next.js App Router.
Générateur de README
Developpement
Crée des README.md professionnels et complets pour vos projets.
Rédacteur de Documentation API
Developpement
Génère de la documentation API complète au format OpenAPI/Swagger.